Time-lapse Evaluation of Human Embryo Development in Single Versus Sequential Culture Media - a Sibling Oocyte Study
Current human IVF technology employs two strategies with respective culture media for embryo development; 'let the embryo choose' (utilizes single step media) and 'back-to-nature' (utilizes sequential media). To our knowledge, there is not any sibling oocyte study to evaluate potential advantages/disadvantages of these strategies on one another.
|Study Design:||Observational Model: Case Control
Time Perspective: Prospective
|Official Title:||Time-lapse Evaluation of Human Embryo Development in Single Versus Sequential Culture Media - a Sibling Oocyte Study|
|Study Start Date:||March 2011|
|Estimated Study Completion Date:||January 2012|
|Primary Completion Date:||December 2011 (Final data collection date for primary outcome measure)|
Sibling oocytes cultured in single or sequential media until day6
Maintaining optimal embryo development during in vitro culture is a key element in assisted reproduction treatments. Whether the concept of mimicking in vivo environment is a 'must' in order not to compromise outcome is a matter of debate since 'let the embryo choose' strategy has been shown to perform at least as good as the 'back to nature' in several studies.'Let the embryo choose" approach utilizes a milieu with relatively constant concentration of ingredients (single culture system) as compared to the latter, in which demands of the embryos are supported according to their passage from the Fallopian tubes to the uterus in a sequential culture media. Basic differences between these ingredients are; presence of (1) glucose instead of pyruvate, and (2) essential aminoacids in early embryo stages (until day 3) in single step media, and (3) presence of EDTA in sequential media.
Vast majority of these results were obtained from studies where patients have been randomized into groups instead of employing a sibling (oocyte/embryo) model which could have enabled each patient to serve as her own control. In fact, it has been claimed that introducing a sibling oocyte study design could give a methodological problem at the time of fertilization since different type of culture media vary in osmolarity. Likewise the only study that employed a sibling oocyte model utilized two different media (home-made versus G1.2/G1.2) although the osmolarity of the former had been adjusted to 280-285 mOsm). This study reported no significant differences in day3/5 embryo development as well as pregnancy/implantation rates between groups.
Subsequent studies, however, favoured single step media, as they found higher proportion of compacted embryos to zygotes at day3, morula at 4, a higher blastocyst yield, an overall higher utilization rate after day5 and an improved implantation rate when compared to sequential media. Yet, besides potential variation of gamete qualities between patients allocated to groups (as described above), differences in static observation times of embryos between laboratories could have affected the results in these studies. Current introduction of time-lapse equipment into human assisted reproduction technology enabled a more distinct definition of embryo development and it is now possible to quantify pace of embryo cleavage in various media. Such a definition is also useful to determine the predictive value of embryo development in pre-defined time points will be applicable to all embryology laboratories using various culture systems.
|Bahceci Fulya IVF Clinic||Recruiting|
|Contact: Nadir Ciray, MD., PhD +90 2123103100|
|Sub-Investigator: Mustafa Bahceci, MD|
|Principal Investigator:||Nadir H Ciray, MD., PhD||Bahceci Health Group|
|Study Chair:||Turan Aksoy, BS||Bahceci Health Group|
|Study Director:||Mustafa Bahceci, MD||Bahceci Health Group|
|Study Chair:||Cihan Goktas, BS||Bahceci Health Group|
|Study Chair:||Birgen Ozturk, BS||Bahceci Health Group|